Mel's Hole.
In 1997, a man who called himself Mel Waters phoned a late-night paranormal radio show and described a hole on his land near Ellensburg, Washington that had no bottom — he'd lowered fishing line past fifteen miles and never touched it. Over the years the story grew: the hole revived dead pets, swallowed light, and was finally seized by the government. It became one of the most beloved legends in American radio. There is just one problem, and it is the whole file: no hole, no land, and no Mel Waters was ever found.
AnomalyDesk is reader-supported. Articles may contain affiliate links to books and primary-document collections. Read our full funding disclosure.
What Mel's Hole is, in a paragraph.
Mel's Hole is a modern legend that originated as a call to the late-night radio program Coast to Coast AM in February 1997. A caller identifying himself as “Mel Waters” told host Art Bell that he owned rural land near Ellensburg, Washington, on which there was a hole of apparently unlimited depth. According to Waters, the hole was an ordinary-looking pit about nine feet across, ringed by old debris, that locals had used for decades to dump trash — and yet it never seemed to fill. He claimed to have lowered fishing line into it past 80,000 feet (more than fifteen miles) without reaching a bottom, that objects lowered in produced no sound of impact, and that the hole displayed a range of supernatural properties: it did not echo, a “black beam” that absorbed light, radios that picked up broadcasts seemingly from the past, animals that refused to go near it, and — the story's most-repeated flourish — a neighbor's dead dog thrown into the hole, later seen alive in the woods. In later call-ins over several years, the tale escalated: Waters said the government had seized his land, paid him to stay away, and that the hole had further wonders. The story became a signature piece of Coast to Coast lore and spread widely in paranormal culture. Against all of this stands a simple evidentiary vacuum: the hole has never been located or shown to exist; no property or public records confirm a “Mel Waters” owning land in the area; investigators and journalists who looked found nothing to corroborate the account; and geologists note that the local geology does not support a natural shaft of the described depth (the area has ordinary terrain and some old mine workings, nothing remotely like a fifteen-mile pit — which would also be physically impossible to keep open). The claims are, moreover, unfalsifiable by design: the one man who could show the hole won't, the land is supposedly off-limits, and every wonder is described rather than demonstrated. Taken together, Mel's Hole is best classified as modern folklore — a compelling, unverifiable tall tale born on the radio, in the tradition of the campfire bottomless-pit story updated for the late-night call-in era. Its interest for this archive is not as an open geological mystery (it is not one) but as a clean, well-documented example of how a legend forms and propagates when a good story meets a medium that rewards them and asks for no proof.
The documented record.
The broadcasts are real
The origin is well-documented. Verified A caller named “Mel Waters” described the hole on Coast to Coast AM beginning in February 1997, with follow-up call-ins over subsequent years — these broadcasts are a matter of record [1][2].
The hole has never been found
No physical site exists in the record. Verified Despite wide interest, no one has located or documented the hole, and journalists and enthusiasts who searched the Ellensburg / Manastash Ridge area found nothing matching the description [2][3].
“Mel Waters” is unverified
The source cannot be confirmed. Verified No property or public records establish a “Mel Waters” owning the described land; the caller's real identity and existence were never confirmed [2][3].
The geology argues against it
A fifteen-mile pit is not physically plausible. Disputed Geologists note the local terrain does not support a natural shaft of the claimed depth, which could not remain open; the region has ordinary ground and some old mine workings [3].
The competing positions.
Believers hold that the hole is real and either paranormal or government-suppressed, pointing to Waters's detailed, repeated accounts and the “seizure” of his land as reasons no evidence can be produced. Unverified This is unfalsifiable: every check that fails is explained by the same secrecy that prevents the check [1][2].
The evidence-based position is that Mel's Hole is a tall tale or hoax that became folklore — a vivid, escalating story with no locatable site, no verifiable source, and no physical plausibility. Disputed This archive treats it as unverified modern legend, documented as a cultural phenomenon rather than a geological one, without asserting bad faith on any named individual [2][3].
The unanswered questions.
Any physical hole
The central object is absent. Verified The one thing that would move this from legend to mystery — a located, measurable hole — has never been produced [2][3].
The identity of the caller
The source is anonymous. Claimed Who “Mel Waters” actually was, and what motivated the calls, is unknown; various attempts to identify him have not succeeded [2].
How the details spread and grew
The legend's evolution is only partly traced. Claimed Exactly how the story accreted new wonders across broadcasts and retellings is a study in folklore rather than a resolved record [1].
Primary material.
The accessible record on Mel's Hole is held principally in these sources:
- The Coast to Coast AM broadcasts (from February 1997 onward) in which “Mel Waters” described the hole.
- Journalistic investigations into the location and the caller's identity, which found no corroboration.
- Local geological and public-record checks of the Ellensburg / Manastash Ridge area.
- Folklore and media analyses treating Mel's Hole as a modern legend.
Critical individual sources include: the original broadcasts; the investigative reporting; and the geological/records checks.
The sequence.
- February 1997 “Mel Waters” first describes the bottomless hole on Coast to Coast AM.
- Late 1990s–2000s Follow-up call-ins add new claims — reviving animals, a government seizure of the land, further wonders.
- Ongoing Searches by journalists and enthusiasts fail to locate the hole or verify the caller.
- Present Mel's Hole endures as a signature piece of paranormal-radio folklore, unverified and unsupported.
Full bibliography.
- Archives and summaries of the Coast to Coast AM broadcasts featuring “Mel Waters” (from February 1997).
- Journalistic investigations into the location of Mel's Hole and the identity of the caller.
- Geological commentary and Kittitas County public-record checks of the Ellensburg / Manastash Ridge area.
- Folklore and media-studies treatments of Mel's Hole as a modern legend.
Frequently asked questions.
What is Mel's Hole?
A legend about an apparently bottomless hole on rural land near Ellensburg, Washington, described on the radio show Coast to Coast AM in 1997 by a caller named "Mel Waters." The hole was said to have supernatural properties, but it has never been located or shown to exist.
Is Mel's Hole real?
There is no evidence that it is. No such hole has ever been found, no public records confirm a "Mel Waters" owning the land, and geologists say a natural shaft of the claimed depth (over 80,000 feet) is not physically possible. It is best understood as modern radio folklore.
Where is Mel's Hole supposed to be?
The caller placed it on his property near Ellensburg, in the Manastash Ridge area of Kittitas County, Washington — but he never disclosed a verifiable location, and later claimed the government had seized the land, which conveniently made the site impossible to check.
Who was Mel Waters?
Unknown. The caller's real identity was never confirmed, and attempts to trace him or any matching property records have not succeeded. That the single source is anonymous and unverifiable is central to why the story remains a legend rather than a documented mystery.